- HMS Community Values
- Introduction to Clinical Research Training
- Letter from the Chairman
- Medical Education
- Application Form and Instructions
- United Kingdom Clinical Scholars Research Training
- Award Listing
- Vanderbilt Hall
- Award Summaries
- Financial Aid
- Spring Preview
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Office of the Registrar
- Award Recipients
- Campus Planning and Facilities
- Ombuds Office
- Research Administration Contacts
- Committee on Microbiological Safety
- Contact Us
- Human Resources
- The Academy
- Office for Academic and Clinical Affairs
- Joint Committee on the Status of Women
- Global Health Research Core
- Administration Who's Who
- Cafeteria Menus
- Community Announcements
- HR Stories
- Faces of HMS
- Safety Tips
- Longwood Shuttles & MBTA
- Spotlight Stories
- Inaugural Pride on the Quad Day
- Spring Cleaning: Earth Week 2015
- Celebrating the Past, Preparing for the Future
- Spotlight on External Education
- A Work in Progress
- HMS to Oversee Undiagnosed Diseases Network
- New Recycling and Reuse Resource
- Growing Green: Sustainability Committee Covers Harvard Longwood Campus
- Study by HMS student evaluates FDA approval of cardiac devices
- Play Me, I'm Yours!
- Exploring the Nervous System
- HMS Brings Comfort and Convenience to New Mothers
- RIA Program
- Spotlight on Angela DePace
- Spotlight on Admissions
- Spotlight on Rick Born
- Spotlight on the New Year
- Backing Up Science on the Quad
- Combating a Crisis
- Improved policies, improved care
- Strengthening Collaborations
- Contact Us
- Global Clinical Scholars Research Training Program
- HMA Standing Committee on Animals
- Office of Research Compliance
- Harvard Medical School Event Calendar
- Office of Diversity RIA Program
- The Dean's Perspective
- Department of Pathology
- Harvard Mahoney Neuroscience Institute
- OHRA Home
- Office of Research Subject Protection
- Alumni Association
- Cancer Biology & Therapeutics Program
- Celiac Program
- Department of Medicine
- HMS Information Technology
- HMS TransMed Program
- Introduction to the Practice of American Medicine
- Office of Communications & External Relations
- Big Data In Healthcare
- Institutional Planning and Policy
- Master of Medical Sciences In Clinical Investigation
- Office of Global Education
- Portugal Clinical Scholars Research Training Program
- Safety Quality Informatics and Leadership
- South American Clinical Research Training Program | SACRT
- Southeast Asia Leadership Program
- Shenzhen-HMS Initiative in International Education
- Contact @HMS
- Office of Global Education
- Human Resources
- Jobs @ HMS
- Dental Medicine
- Harvard University
- Contact us
Startling Benefit of Cardiology Meetings
High-risk patients with certain acute heart conditions are more likely to survive than other similar patients if they are admitted to the hospital during national cardiology meetings, when many cardiologists are away from their regular practices.
Sixty percent of patients with cardiac arrest who were admitted to a teaching hospital during the days when cardiologists were at scientific meetings died within 30 days, compared to 70 percent of patients who were admitted on non-meeting days.
“That’s a tremendous reduction in mortality, better than most of the medical interventions that exist to treat these conditions,” said study senior author Anupam Jena, assistant professor of health care policy at HMS, internist at Massachusetts General Hospital and faculty research fellow at the National Bureau of Economic Research. There is substantial ambiguity in how medical care is practiced, particularly for these complex patients, he said. “This study may help illuminate some of those gray areas and suggest ways we can provide better care for those high-risk patients.”
The results of the study were published Dec. 22 in JAMA Internal Medicine.
Along with collaborators at the National Institutes of Health, the Leonard D. Schaeffer Center for Health Policy and Economics at the University of Southern California, Los Angeles, and the RAND Corporation, Jena compared similar populations of patients treated at teaching and nonteaching hospitals during American Heart Association and American College of Cardiology meetings and on matched dates immediately surrounding those meetings. They looked at survival rates of high-risk and low-risk patients with heart failure, heart attack and cardiac arrest.
While survival rates at teaching hospitals went up during meetings for high-risk heart failure and for cardiac arrest, there was no difference in mortality between meeting and non-meeting dates for patients with high-risk heart attack or for low-risk patients with any of the conditions studied. There was also no change in mortality rates for any patients for any of the conditions in nonteaching hospitals.
“We don’t have the full set of answers about what works best in these cases, but the evidence suggests that a less is more approach might be best for higher-risk patients with these conditions,” Jena said.
The researchers found that certain intensive procedures were performed less often on the high-risk patients in the study during meeting dates than outside meeting dates.
One explanation for these findings, the researchers said, is that physicians who don’t attend the conferences take a more conservative approach for high-risk patients; another is that the physicians who stayed behind were reluctant to perform intensive procedures on another physician’s patients while that doctor was out of town. Survival rates might be higher because, for high-risk patients with cardiovascular disease, the harms of intensive procedures may unexpectedly outweigh the benefits.
High-risk patients are typically older people with complicated medical histories and clinical profiles that make them especially vulnerable to the illnesses studied and, perhaps, to some of the more intensive methods used to treat these conditions.
Little is known scientifically about the benefit of many interventions for high-risk patients: A 50-year-old overweight smoker having a heart attack is a classic candidate for certain intensive interventions, such as coronary artery stenting, based on the effectiveness of those procedures in clinical trials conducted on other similar patients. More complex, higher risk cases might not benefit from or tolerate the same interventions in the same way.
Clinical trials teach us a great deal about how to treat a certain subset of patients, most often low- to moderate-risk patients, Jena said. Many trials do not enlist the highest risk patients, and it may be incorrect for physicians to assume that patients of all risk levels should be treated the same.
“Our study provides some evidence that treating high-risk patients the same as lower-risk patients may be bad medicine,” Jena said.
The researchers speculated that differences in survival rates were detected only among patients treated at teaching hospitals because of the higher concentration of physicians from a teaching hospital who would be likely to attend a scientific meeting. Detailed information about the demographics of attendees at the meetings was not available for the study.
The study was inspired by prior research showing that patients hospitalized on weekends and late at night have worse outcomes than those who become ill during regular office hours, due to lower overall staffing levels during off hours. What might happen, the researchers asked, when overall staffing levels remained the same but the number of physicians dropped?
Every year, thousands of physicians attend scientific meetings. The researchers chose to study cardiology because cardiac conditions are often acute, with sudden onset, and a patient’s treatment cannot be easily rescheduled to accommodate a physician’s travel schedule. The researchers said they expected to find that patient outcomes were worse when physicians were out of town and so were surprised by the results of the study.
This research was funded by the Office of the Director, National Institutes of Health (NIH Early Independence Award, grant 1DP5OD017897-01 and the National Institute on Aging (grant 5P01AG033559).
Stay informed via email on the latest news, research, and
media from Harvard Medical School.