Breast Cancer Switchbacks

Spontaneous changes between HER2-positive and HER2-negative states may aid tumor growth

Breast MRI. Image: National Cancer Institute

A study led by Harvard Medical School investigators at Massachusetts General Hospital reveals how spontaneous changes in the molecular characteristics of tumors can lead to tumors with a mixed population of cells requiring treatment with several types of therapeutic drugs.

Get more HMS news here

In their report in Nature, the research team describes finding a mixture of HER2-positive and HER2-negative circulating tumors cells (CTCs) in blood samples from patients who developed metastatic disease after originally being diagnosed with estrogen-receptor (ER)-positive/HER2-negative breast cancer.

"This population of tumor cells is able to spontaneously oscillate between HER2-positive and HER2-negative states."—Shyamala Maheswaran

“Not only did we observe the acquisition of HER2 positivity in patients with ER-positive/HER2 negative breast tumors, we also found that this population of tumor cells is able to spontaneously oscillate between HER2-positive and HER2-negative states, which contributes to tumor progression and resistance,” said Shyamala Maheswaran, HMS associate professor of surgery at Mass General and co-senior author of the paper. “We also showed in mouse models the types of therapies that may be most useful for patients with these difficult-to-treat tumors.”

Molecular heterogeneity

Molecular heterogeneity of tumors has become a confounding factor in cancer treatment in recent years, requiring the use of multiple drugs that specifically target all the different cell populations driving tumor growth. The current study was designed to investigate further the differences in HER2 expression that can occur in individual patients’ tumors and how they affect tumor growth and treatment.

Using the CTC-iChip—a microfluidic device developed at the Mass General Center for Engineering in Medicine that isolates CTCs from blood samples—the researchers found both HER2-positive and HER2-negative CTCs in samples from 16 out of 18 patients who had developed metastases after treatment for ER-positive/HER2-negative breast cancer.

CTCs isolated from patients with ER-positive/HER2-negative breast cancer and grown in culture also showed a similar pattern of HER2 expression, in which some of the tumor cells expressed HER2 and some did not. Closer examination of these HER2-positive tumor cells showed elevated expression of proteins in several growth signaling pathways, but the level of HER2 expression was not as high as seen in HER2-amplified primary tumors.

Combined treatment

These HER2-positive CTCs were no more sensitive to treatment with a HER2-inhibiting drug than were HER2-negative CTCs, but combined treatment with both the HER2 inhibitor and an IGFR1 (insulin-like growth factor receptor 1) inhibitor was toxic to HER2-positive CTCs. In contrast, HER2-negative CTCs had elevated expression of proteins in the Notch developmental pathway and in pathways that respond to DNA damage.

Reflecting those differences, HER2-positive CTCs were found to proliferate more rapidly and respond to treatment with standard chemotherapy drugs, while HER2-negative CTCs were more resistant to chemotherapy drugs but sensitive to gamma secretase inhibitors, which are known to suppress Notch signaling.

Injecting either HER2-positive or HER2-negative breast tumor cells into the mammary tissue of mice led to the development of tumors with both types of cells. Treatment of tumors in which HER2-positive cells were predominant with the chemotherapy drug paclitaxel led to rapid tumor shrinkage, followed by recurrence with a greater number of HER2-negative cells, while paclitaxel treatment of tumors with more HER2-negative cells did not have any effect.

“The ability of these two populations of tumor cells to convert back and forth highlights the importance of treating tumors with drugs that would simultaneously target both populations.”—Shyamala Maheswaran

Treating mice in which tumors had been initiated by a mixture of HER2-positive and HER2-negative tumor cells with a combination of paclitaxel and a gamma secretase inhibitor did delay tumor recurrence significantly, suggesting the potential utility of a combination treatment strategy to eliminate this mixed population of tumor cells.

“The ability of these two populations of tumor cells to convert back and forth highlights the importance of treating tumors with drugs that would simultaneously target both populations,” said Maheswaran. “Now we need to investigate the mechanisms responsible for this interconversion.”

Daniel A. Haber, the Kurt J. Isselbacher/Peter Schwartz Professor of Oncology at HMS and director of the Mass General Cancer Center, is co-senior author of the Nature paper.

Support for the study includes National Institutes of Health grant 2RO1 CA129933 and grants from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, the Breast Cancer Research Foundation, the National Foundation for Cancer Research, the Wellcome Trust and the Susan G. Komen foundation.

Adapted from a Mass General news release.