- HMS Community Values
- Introduction to Clinical Research Training
- Medical Education
- Dean for Medical Education
- Financial Aid
- Student Services
- MD Programs
- Student Handbook
- Education Matters
- Student Profiles
- Curriculum Services
- The Academy at Harvard Medical School
- Program Evaluation and Student Assessment
- Anatomical Gift Program
- Contact Us
- Teaching Awards
- United Kingdom Clinical Scholars Research Training
- Vanderbilt Hall
- Financial Aid
- Office of the Registrar
- Campus Planning and Facilities
- Ombuds Office
- Committee on Microbiological Safety
- Human Resources
- HMS Foundation Funds
- The Academy
- Office for Academic and Clinical Affairs
- Joint Committee on the Status of Women
- Global Health Research Core
- Global Clinical Scholars Research Training Program
- HMA Standing Committee on Animals
- Office of Research Compliance
- Harvard Medical School Event Calendar
- Contact @HMS
- Office of Diversity RIA Program
- The Dean's Perspective
- Department of Pathology
- Harvard Mahoney Neuroscience Institute
- OHRA Home
- Office of Research Subject Protection
- Tools and Technology
- Alumni Association
- Cancer Biology & Therapeutics Program
- Celiac Program
- Department of Medicine
- HMS Information Technology
- HMS TransMed Program
- Introduction to the Practice of American Medicine
- Office of Communications & External Relations
- Big Data In Healthcare
- Institutional Planning and Policy
- Master of Medical Sciences In Clinical Investigation
- Office of Global Education
- Portugal Clinical Scholars Research Training Program
- Safety Quality Informatics and Leadership
- Shenzhen-HMS Initiative in International Education
- South American Clinical Research Training
- test page
- Human Resources
- Jobs @ HMS
- Dental Medicine
- Harvard University
- Contact us
Educational Research Review Process
Educational Research Review Process
The Academy is responsible for the scientific review and approval of educational research with HMS students as research subjects. The Academy Scientific Review Committee will review the application to ensure proposals meet acceptable standards of scientific rigor and merit and align with the HMS educational mission, values, and priorities. All questions related to the Academy approval process can be directed to firstname.lastname@example.org.
HMS Priorities for research with students include: research related to curriculum change efforts; studies that provide evidence for specific pedagogic approaches that are not already demonstrated to be effective in existing literature; research that will contribute to theoretical or conceptual models of teaching and learning.
In general, studies that are limited in generalizability, focus narrowly on career choice in a specific field, or attitudes toward particular topics of study are not likely to receive approval. In particular, because requests to conduct surveys have increased in recent years, we encourage faculty who wish to conduct surveys to ensure that the survey instrument is of high quality, has been validated or sufficiently pilot-tested, and is as brief as possible (preferably 15 minutes or less). Consultation is available through the Academy Office for Research for faculty who wish to have their survey reviewed prior to proposal submission.
How do I get started?
You will need to submit your proposal either on your hospital's IRB forms OR on the HMS IRB's forms (available at irb.harvard.edu). Please contact the Academy Office of Education Research for guidance.
What is the process for review?
Step 1: Prepare the following documents for submission: Checklist for Proposal Submission
- Protocol (available at http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/ohra/formsinstructions/)
- Please be sure to give background, prior literature, importance of study, target population, sample size, justification, methods of data collection and analysis, and expected response rate.
- Instruments (surveys, interview guides, other)
- Consent form(s) (if applicable)
- Letter of Support (e-mail is acceptable) from clerkship or course director(s), if applicable
- Recruitment materials (flyers, brochures, email text, study fact sheets) (if applicable)
- Cover letter addressed to the Academy Review Team, describing the following (1) title and purpose of study; (2) importance of study; (3) which medical students (and how many) will be invited to participate (for example, all first year students (n=165), or all students participating in a specific hospital clerkship; (4) justification for selecting students as target population rather than other groups (for example, why is it relevant for students rather than residents, or year 2 students rather than year 4 students; (5) time required for student participation; and (6) if a new curricular component is being added to a course or clerkship, what existing elements it will be replacing. If your study involves a course or clerkship and you are the course or clerkship director, please state so in your letter; if you are not the course or clerkship director, please provide the name of the director and confirm that you have included documentation of approval for the study from the director.
Step 2: Academy Review Team review
The Academy Office will send investigators a link to a brief online form where they can describe the involvement of students and timing of data collection. This will allow Academy reviewers to assess the potential research burden on students.
• Academy reviewers will review the protocol for scientific merit, alignment with HMS curricular priorities, and student burden. Initial review results will fall into one of three categories: approved, conditional approval, or not approved. There are many requests to conduct research studies with students as participants, so unfortunately not all proposals can be approved. Applicants who receive conditional approval may choose to revise and resubmit their application. Academy reviewers will provide feedback to investigators within one week.
• Studies that are approved by Academy reviewers are forwarded to the Dean for Students (for survey studies) and the Dean for Education (all studies).
Step 3: IRB review
• The Academy will notify the IRB of the outcome of the Academy review. Studies that receive approval from the Academy and the Offices of the Dean for Students and Dean for Medical Education will be reviewed by the IRB. IRB reviewers will work directly with the PI to address any IRB-related concerns or requirements for revision.
Information and forms for submitting your application are available at irb.harvard.edu
Office of Human Research Administration http://hms.harvard.edu/departments/office-human-research-administration
IRB Investigator Manual: http://hms.harvard.edu/departments/office-human-research-administration/investigator-manual
To create and nurture a diverse community of the best people committed to leadership in alleviating human suffering caused by disease